Early 2025 MLB Season Review: Identifying Top Performers And Underachievers

Mei Lin

4 min read

Post on May 14, 2025

4.8

Share

Top Performing Teams of Early 2025

Statistical Analysis of Leading Teams

Analyzing win-loss records, run differentials, batting averages, and ERAs paints a clear picture of the early season leaders. These key metrics reveal which teams have truly dominated.

• Top 5 Teams:
  • New York Yankees: Boasting a powerful lineup and stellar pitching, the Yankees have maintained a commanding lead, showcasing their consistent early season success. Aaron Judge's continued dominance at the plate has been a key factor.
  • Los Angeles Dodgers: The Dodgers' balanced roster, featuring both strong hitting and reliable pitching, has allowed them to consistently win close games. Their deep pitching rotation is a key component of their success.
  • Atlanta Braves: The Braves' young talent has continued to shine, displaying exceptional teamwork and a high offensive output, making them a formidable force. Their consistent hitting and solid defense have powered their early season success.
  • Houston Astros: The Astros’ potent offense and experienced pitching staff have allowed them to overcome early challenges and maintain a strong position. Their consistent performance showcases their experience and team cohesion.
  • Texas Rangers: The Rangers' surprising early season success is due in large part to their dominant pitching and improved defense. Their ability to prevent runs has been pivotal in their strong start.

Unexpected Contenders

Several teams have emerged as dark horse contenders, exceeding all expectations.

• Baltimore Orioles: A significantly improved pitching staff has turned the Orioles into a surprise contender, showcasing a remarkable turnaround from previous years. Their unexpected success is a testament to their team's overall improvement.
• Seattle Mariners: The Mariners' young talent has finally blossomed, with several key players posting career-best offensive numbers. Their surprise performance stems from an incredible team effort.
• Toronto Blue Jays: The Blue Jays’ powerful offense and improved bullpen have catapulted them into unexpected contention. Their improved pitching has been a key contributor to their early season success.

Underachieving Teams of Early 2025

Statistical Analysis of Struggling Teams

Conversely, some teams have faced significant early season struggles, reflected in their low win-loss records and poor statistical performance.

• Bottom 5 Teams:
  • Boston Red Sox: The Red Sox are suffering from inconsistent hitting and a struggling bullpen, resulting in disappointing results and leading to major concerns. They need to address their defensive vulnerabilities to improve.
  • Chicago Cubs: The Cubs have been plagued by injuries, significantly impacting their lineup and pitching rotation, leading to their underperforming record. Their inability to maintain a consistent starting lineup is a major contributing factor.
  • Philadelphia Phillies: Despite high expectations, the Phillies have encountered significant early season struggles, including an underperforming offense. Their disappointing results highlight the need for immediate improvements across the board.
  • St. Louis Cardinals: The Cardinals’ inconsistent pitching and lack of offensive firepower have led to a poor start to the season. They are a prime example of a team that has fallen short of expectations.
  • Washington Nationals: The Nationals are exhibiting an overall lack of consistency in all aspects of the game, demonstrating disappointing results. Their early season struggles are indicative of a team in need of significant restructuring.

Disappointing Performances from Pre-Season Favorites

Several pre-season favorites have fallen short of expectations.

• New York Mets: High-profile signings haven’t translated into wins, with a significant drop in team performance. Their underwhelming performance raises questions about team chemistry and coaching strategy.
• Los Angeles Angels: Despite having a talented roster, the Angels' inability to consistently score runs has resulted in underperformance. Their pitching has also been a major area for concern.

Individual Player Performances: MVP Candidates and Disappointments

Top MVP Candidates (AL and NL)

Several players have emerged as early MVP candidates based on their outstanding performances.

• AL: Shohei Ohtani (Angels), continues to be a dual threat, leading in both pitching and hitting statistics, making him a strong contender.
• AL: Aaron Judge (Yankees) maintains his dominance, showcasing exceptional power and run production.
• NL: Mookie Betts (Dodgers), demonstrates consistently strong hitting and contributes significantly to his team's success.

Disappointing Individual Performances

Some high-profile players haven't lived up to expectations.

• Bryce Harper (Phillies): Harper’s injury has significantly impacted his performance and the team's overall success.
• Francisco Lindor (Mets): Lindor's struggles at the plate have been a significant factor in the Mets' disappointing start.

Conclusion

The early 2025 MLB season has been full of surprises. While teams like the Yankees and Dodgers have shown consistent dominance, unexpected contenders like the Orioles have emerged. Conversely, pre-season favorites like the Mets have struggled. Individual player performances have also been a rollercoaster, with some exceeding expectations and others falling short. Key takeaways include the importance of consistent pitching and hitting, the impact of injuries, and the unpredictable nature of the game. Keep checking back for our continued coverage of the 2025 MLB season and further analysis of top performers and underachievers.