Man United's Problems: Tagliafico's Assessment Of Ten Hag's Reign

Mei Lin

6 min read

Post on May 23, 2025

4.9

Share

Tactical Flexibility and System Inconsistencies

Tagliafico, having played at the highest level, would undoubtedly have observed inconsistencies in Ten Hag's tactical approach. The question arises: does Ten Hag's seemingly rigid system hinder Man United's adaptability? His preferred style, often a possession-based 4-2-3-1, demands precise execution and high-intensity pressing. However, its inflexibility becomes apparent when facing opponents who effectively neutralize this approach.

Lack of Plan B

Man United have demonstrably struggled to adapt their game plan when facing teams employing different tactical strategies. The reliance on a single system leaves them vulnerable when opponents successfully disrupt their usual build-up play.

• Examples of games where a change in tactics was needed but not implemented: The losses against Brighton and Brentford in the early stages of the season showcased this rigidity, where Man United appeared ill-equipped to deal with high-pressing tactics.
• Specific players who might be better suited to a different system: Players like Bruno Fernandes, while incredibly talented, may thrive in a system that offers more direct attacking options rather than the intricate build-up play often employed by Ten Hag.
• Statistical evidence to support claims of tactical rigidity: Analyzing pass completion rates and possession statistics against different styles of opponents could reveal a lack of adaptability and highlight the need for tactical variation.

Player Suitability

The current squad's composition is another critical factor. Does it truly suit Ten Hag's system? While some players excel under his management, others seem miscast, leading to positional mismatches and overall weaknesses.

• A potential mismatch: The reliance on a specific profile of central midfielder might expose weaknesses if those players are unavailable or underperforming.
• Weaknesses in specific positions: The full-back positions have been areas of concern, impacting the team's defensive solidity and attacking width.
• Statistical comparisons: Comparing player statistics under previous managers with their current performances under Ten Hag can reveal whether players are underperforming or if the system is hindering their capabilities.

Squad Depth and Player Performance

Tagliafico's assessment likely includes an evaluation of Man United's squad depth and individual player performance. While certain positions boast exceptional talent, significant weaknesses exist in other areas.

Key Positional Weaknesses

Man United's squad lacks sufficient depth and quality in several crucial areas. A lack of viable alternatives impacts performance and resilience, especially when key players suffer injuries or suspensions.

• Specific areas needing reinforcement: The right-back position remains a consistent area of concern, and additional creative midfielders could provide valuable support to Bruno Fernandes and Christian Eriksen.
• Impact of injuries and suspensions: The lack of cover at key positions has often forced Ten Hag to play players out of position, undermining tactical effectiveness and overall team performance.

Underperforming Star Players

Some high-profile players haven't met expectations under Ten Hag's management. This can stem from various factors, including tactical mismatches, injuries, or simply a failure to adapt to the new system.

• Examples of underperforming players: Certain players, although talented, have struggled to maintain consistent performances under Ten Hag's demanding regime.
• Impact on team dynamics: The underperformance of key players creates a ripple effect, impacting team morale and overall results.
• Statistical comparison to previous seasons: A comparative analysis of individual and team statistics across previous seasons and the current season reveals the extent of underperformance.

Team Cohesion and Chemistry

A successful team requires strong team spirit and chemistry. Tagliafico's assessment likely touched upon the team's atmosphere and on-field cohesion.

Lack of On-Field Connection

Despite individual brilliance, Man United have at times exhibited poor communication and coordination on the field. This lack of cohesion can lead to defensive errors and a lack of fluidity in attacking moves.

• Instances of poor communication: Instances where defensive breakdowns can be attributed to poor communication and coordination need to be analysed to understand why and implement corrective solutions.
• Impact on overall performance: The lack of cohesive play between players undermines the effectiveness of the tactics and significantly affects results.

Impact of New Signings

The integration of new signings into the existing squad is crucial. Some players may seamlessly adapt, while others require time to adjust to a new system and team dynamics.

• Successful integrations: Casemiro's immediate impact highlights the importance of successful integration of new players.
• Challenges with integration: Some new signings have struggled to find their rhythm within the team, impacting the overall chemistry of the squad.
• Assessment of team atmosphere: Analyzing reports and observations on the overall team atmosphere can provide insights into how well the new signings have integrated socially.

Transfer Strategy and Future Outlook

Manchester United's transfer policy plays a significant role in their success or failure. Tagliafico's perspective might offer insights into the effectiveness of the club's recruitment strategy.

Successful and Unsuccessful Transfers

Assessing the impact of recent signings is critical. Some acquisitions have proven beneficial, while others haven't met expectations.

• Examples of successful transfers: Casemiro's arrival has significantly strengthened the midfield.
• Examples of less successful transfers: Some signings have failed to make a significant contribution to the team's overall performance.

Areas for Improvement in Recruitment

Identifying areas where Man United needs to strengthen their squad through strategic signings is paramount. A clear understanding of the team's weaknesses and future needs is essential for effective recruitment.

• Areas requiring reinforcements: The club needs to address the full-back situation, potentially adding depth and competition.
• Player profiles for future signings: The club needs to identify specific player profiles to complement existing players and address their existing weaknesses.

Predictions for Man United’s Future Success

Based on current circumstances and observations, predicting Man United's future trajectory is challenging. Addressing the identified weaknesses, improving tactical flexibility, strengthening team cohesion, and refining transfer strategies are crucial for future success.

Conclusion

Nicolás Tagliafico's implied assessment offers a valuable external perspective on the multifaceted challenges facing Manchester United under Erik ten Hag. Addressing tactical inflexibility, bolstering squad depth, fostering stronger team cohesion, and refining transfer strategies are crucial steps for the club's return to top-flight competition. To fully grasp the complexity of Man United's struggles, further detailed analysis of Ten Hag's managerial decisions and individual player performances is required. Continue reading our in-depth analyses on Man United's problems to stay updated on the latest developments and gain a deeper understanding of the club's challenges and potential solutions.